Commentary on the Readings
Fourth sunday of easter - May 3, 2020
Why does a bride cry?
The pharaoh questions them about their occupations. Joseph’s brothers say, “Your servants are shepherds as were our fathers before us” (Gen 47:3). The patriarchs were shepherds. Moses was the keeper of flocks and David was taken from the pastures while following the sheep (1 Chr 17:7).
Throughout the ancient Middle East, the ruler who takes care of his people is imagined as a shepherd. In the Mesopotamian inscriptions “to pasture” is commonly used in the sense of “govern.” The pharaoh was called the “the shepherd of all nations,” “shepherd who watches over his subjects” and, as a symbol of his power, he was holding the crook.
In Israel, this image is applied to military and political leaders, and also to God.
The invocation “Listen, O shepherd of Israel, you who lead Joseph like a flock” (Ps 80:2) is moving.The famous song “The Lord is my shepherd; I shall not want” (Psalm 23:1) communicates a pleasant sensation of security.
Surprisingly, no text of the Old Testament says that the reigning king is designated as a “shepherd.” This title is reserved for a single king, the future Messiah, a descendant of David. After having uttered harsh words of condemnation against the rulers who have led the people to ruin, the Lord promises to personally assume the office of shepherd, to gather the scattered flock, to lead it to the pasture and announces: “Over them I will put one shepherd, my servant David who will tend them and be a true shepherd among them” (Ez 34:23-24).
The prophecy is fulfilled in Jesus.
To internalize the message, we repeat:
“We were going astray like sheep; we now have a shepherd who guides us.”
The reading of Peter’s speech which began last Sunday continues today. He presented the life of Jesus (… a man who went about doing good to all) to the people of Jerusalem. Then he aimed a heavy accusation at his hearers: “You delivered him to sinners to be crucified and killed” (2:23). Finally, he recalled the work of God who has glorified his faithful servant, raising him from the dead. The speech continues from this point: “Let Israel then know for sure that God has made Lord and Christ this Jesus whom you crucified” (v. 36).
On hearing these words, all those present become aware of the committed error. They feel “cut to the heart” by repentance and seek a solution to their inner drama. Not finding it, they address to the apostles a heartfelt question: “What shall we do, brothers?” (v. 37). It is the expression of their total availability to follow, without preclusion, the path that the Lord will show them.
The Word of God is always a denunciation of sin and is a call to renewal, to conversion; it is “sharper than any two-edged sword,” (Heb 4:12), pierces the heart (Heb 4:12), uncovers every weakness, wickedness, and mistake.
Faced with this word, the only honest attitude is the humble listening, availability to let oneself be challenged, to change, and to disown the mistakes of the past, in order to start a new life. Peter’s response shows the three stages that mark the path of salvation: the conversion from the old life and from the mistakes made, baptism, and the joy of receiving the gift of the Spirit (v. 38).
Peter’s exhortation to the newly baptized continues. Toward the end of his speech, the apostle feels the need to address a really delicate social problem: the rapport between masters and slaves. He must touch the subject because, among those who have been baptized are noble and wealthy people as well as many slaves. Some of them, particularly the lucky ones, are employed by good and gentle masters; but others have to deal with tough, rude, arrogant people and haughty, insolent matrons. To the arrogance of the bosses, the harassment and bullying by fellow slaves are added. They take it on Christians who, after baptism, have broken their old habits and have assumed a way of life above reproach. How to deal with those who provoke, offend, ill-treat, do injustices? Must we rebel? Can one react by resorting to violence?
The response of the preacher refers to Jesus and the way he responded to injustice: he could count on twelve legions of angels, but not on twelve fearful disciples. He delivered himself helplessly to those who had come with swords and clubs to arrest him (Mt 26:47). He condemned the use of the sword as a means to restore justice (Mt 26:53). He called Judas “friend” when he delivered Jesus into the hands of the enemies (Mt 26:50). On the cross, he forgave those who were killing him (Lk 23:34). The preacher summarizes the behavior of Jesus referring to the famous book of the prophet Isaiah who presents the faithful servant of the Lord: “He had done no violence nor spoken in deceit” (Is 53:9) and continues: “He did not return insult for insult, and when suffering, he did not curse” (v. 23).
These radical choices of the Master leave to the disciple one, clear and unambiguous path: that of forgiveness and that of unconditional love. The use of violence is contrary to the message of Jesus. To build a new world where justice, peace, and love reign, the Christian can only use the resources offered by Christ, never those which he explicitly rejected.
The reading ends with an image that vividly sums up this message: “You were going astray like sheep, but you have now returned to the shepherd and guardian of your souls.” Belonging to the flock of Jesus the shepherd means to follow in his footsteps, to renounce hatred, grudges, vengeance and to make one’s own, his feelings and gestures of love.
The Fourth Sunday of Easter is called Good Shepherd Sunday because, in each of the three years of the liturgical cycle, a passage of chapter 10 of John’s Gospel is proposed. Today, the first part of this chapter is reported (vv. 1-10) where the theme of Jesus the Good Shepherd is not developed but only hinted at. The central image, in fact, is that of the door. Further on, in his long discourse to the Jews, Jesus proclaims: “I am the good shepherd” (v. 11). Today, he presents himself twice as the door (v. 7). To this image, others are added: the fence, the thieves and robbers, the guardian and strangers. Who are they? Whom do they represent? What is the meaning of the “similitude”?
Let’s assume an explanatory note about the customs of the Palestinian shepherds.
The sheepfold was a pen surrounded by stone walls on which were placed bundles of thorns. Brambles are allowed to grow on it to prevent sheep from exiting and thieves from entering. The pen could be in front of a house, built outdoors, or on the slope of a mountain. In the latter case it was typically used by most shepherds who bring their sheep at night; one of them was awake while others slept.
To say—as Luke does in the story of the birth of Jesus (Lk 2:8)—that those who stood guard “watched” is not entirely accurate. In fact, armed with a stick, he was positioned at the entrance of the fold—that had no door. He squatted and, in that position, blocking the access, he himself became “the door.” Typically, he dozed off, but his presence was enough to deter the raiders from approaching the fold and to prevent the wolves from getting into the enclosure. The sheep could be approached only by whoever he allowed to pass.
In the morning, when every shepherd stood at the door, the sheep immediately recognize his step and voice. They get up and followed him, sure to be carried out in the pastures of fresh herbs and oasis with pure and abundant water. They followed him because they felt loved and protected; the shepherd had never disappointed nor betrayed them.
From this experience of his people’s life, Jesus sets a parable that is not immediately clear: enigmatic images accumulate and overlap, and the Jews did not understand what he was saying to them (v. 6).
Let us begin by dividing it into two parts.
In the first part (vv. 1-6) the figure of the true shepherd is introduced. The beginning of the speech is rather abrupt and provocative. It contains mysterious allusions to dangers, enemies, attackers: “Anyone who does not enter the sheepfold by the gate but climbs in some other way, is a thief and a robber” (v. 1). Then the true shepherd enters the scene. The feature that sets him apart is tenderness: he knows his sheep by name; and calls them “one by one.”
For Jesus, anonymous masses do not exist. He takes interest in each of his disciples. He pays attention to the gifts, strengths, and weaknesses of each. He joyfully contemplates the young and agile kids. They frolic and run forward but his thoughtfulness, his attention goes to the weakest of the herd: “He carries the lambs in his bosom, gently leading those that are with young” (Is 40:11). He understands their difficulties, does not force the issues nor impose unsustainable rhythms but evaluates the condition of each, helps and respects.
In contrast to this shepherd, the thieves and bandits appear. Who are they? How can they be recognized? To whom does Jesus refer them to?
In his time there were “shepherds.” There were religious and political leaders posing as attentive guides of the people’s welfare but in reality, they were seeking only their own interests. Their goals were domination, personal prestige, exploitation: their methods were violence and lies.
They were not authentic shepherds. So one day, before the crowd, Jesus was moved with compassion “because they were like sheep without a shepherd.” He led them out, made them lay “on green grass” and distributed to them in abundance the bread and the nourishment of his word (Mk 6:34-44).
Note, in this first part of the Gospel, the insistence on the “voice of the shepherd” that is “heard” (v. 3), “recognized” (v. 4) and immediately distinguished from that of the strangers’ (v. 5). Even after the resurrection, Jesus will be recognized for his voice.
The eyes of the disciples will be misled: He will be taken as a wayfarer, a ghost (Lk 24:15,37), a fisherman (Jn 21:4); but those who heard him could not be mistaken. His voice was unmistakable.
Today this voice continues to resound, crisp and alive in the Word of the Gospel. It is the only one that sounds familiar to the disciple. The others that overlap, though strong and insistent, are not familiar to him.
Whoever is “taught by the Spirit” is able to discern the voice of the shepherd, in the midst of the noise of so many other items. He flees when he hears the steps of thieves and robbers: the impostors who come just to drag him in the paths of death.
In the second part of the passage (vv. 7-10), Jesus appears first as “the gate of the sheep” then as “the gate.” If one keeps in mind the explanation given above, we could say that he is the guardian that is placed at the entry like “gateway.”
The door has a dual function: to let the owners pass and to prevent the entrance of outsiders. These are two functions that are developed, in many allegories, by Jesus.
He is the one who decides who can have access to the sheep and who has to stay away from the flock (vv. 7-8). The one who has assimilated his own feelings and provisions in respect of the sheep, who is willing to give his life as he did, can pass and is recognized as a true shepherd. The thieves and bandits are those who came before him (v. 8). He was certainly not referring to the prophets and the righteous of the Old Testament.
Thieves were the religious and political leaders of his time who exploited, oppressed and caused all sorts of sufferings to the people.
Bandits were revolutionaries who wanted to build a freer and more just society: they cultivated noble ideals but resorted to wrong methods. They fomented hatred for the enemy, preached the use of violence and proposed the use of weapons. The one who acts in this way does not have the same feelings and the same dispositions as Jesus: he does not pass through the door.
In the last verse (v. 10) this opposition is taken up. In a dramatic crescendo, the work of the thief is described: he steals, kills, and destroys. Three verbs that summarize the work of death. Anyone who approaches a man to take his life is “a thief;” he is on the side of evil; he is a “son of the devil” who “was a murderer from the beginning” (Jn 8:44).
The action of the shepherd is antithetical: he comes to bring life and life in abundance.
Through the door, not only shepherds pass but the sheep also enter and exit. Jesus presents himself as the gate also in this sense (v. 9). Only the one who passes through him reaches fertile pastures, finds the “bread that satisfies” (Jn 6) and “water welling up to eternal life” (Jn 4), thus obtaining salvation.
Jesus is a narrow gate (Mt 7:14) because he asks for self-denial, selfless love to others, but it’s the only one that leads to life: all the others are traps, pitfalls which precipitate in abysses of death: “Broad is the gate that leads to destruction and many go that way” (Mt 7:13).
READ: The parable of the good shepherd involves faith. The sheep hear his voice and they follow. The good shepherd promises food and security. He knows each by name. He is also the door, through which, by faith, they enter.
REFLECT: Do you hear the voice of the good shepherd? Since he knows you by name, does this make you feel good?
PRAY: The good shepherd calls you by name. Pray for the grace to listen to his voice in your daily life. Pray for people involved in great disputes, especially those in the land in which Jesus lived.
ACT: Pay attention to names when you meet new people. Learn people’s names and use them.
There is a video by Fr. Fernando Armellini with English subtitles commenting on today’s Gospel reading.